Skip to main content

The Good Schools Guide Blog

The Good Schools Guide Blog

The free standing academy is so yesterday – today's academy has to be part of a chain, the bigger the better, to enable economies of scale and to propagate the parent school's desirable attributes as widely as possible.

The clue is in the name – chain. Not 'federation', with its implied freedom for members to have their own identity within a centralised structure, but 'chain', suggesting constraint, subjugation of the member schools and their heads to the decrees of the executive body. Which is ironic, when government spokespeople proclaim the great virtue of the academy to be autonomy for those 'best placed to decide about what is right for their pupils: the teachers and the head', as opposed to politicians and local authority bureaucrats.

Freedom? What freedom?

In reality there seems to be a loss of freedom all round; schools can be compelled to become academies if Ofsted judges them to be failing; if the local authority is judged to be unable to improve its failing schools, or if so many schools in an authority have become academies that local authority maintenance has become unviable. What the parents, heads or teachers may want has no bearing. Heads whose schools join chains lose their freedom to control how they want to run their schools (in so far as they have any such freedom, in view of the constraints of the testing and exam systems and the Ofsted regime). Teachers are losing the freedom to unite to obtain better pay or work conditions. Children can be forced to attend other schools in a chain further away from their homes. Parents are losing the right to belong to governing bodies – academies are not required to have to have a governing body.

However in other, undesirable, ways academies have too much freedom. Released from local authority supervision and too numerous to be effectively monitored by the eight, inadequately staffed regional commissioners, with responsibility for vast numbers of schools, or the Westminster-based Secretary of State for Education, they are able to get away with manipulating their admissions policies to exclude 'challenging' pupils or those with special needs. The Harris chain has a reputation for 'losing' Year 11 students who would otherwise bring down GCSE results, by engineering moves to other schools before they take their exams. There have been instances of financial irregularities, such as the CEO of the Perry Beeches Trust, who received a second salary through a third party supplier.

Chains' potential

But it would be unfair to condemn all academies. Some chains, set up by very successful schools, have formed a supportive relationship with local struggling schools. Primary schools can benefit from, say, the expertise in modern languages available in a secondary in their chain. Some academies have turned failing schools into thriving ones – Mossbourne Academy, for example, has achieved spectacular results in an area of high deprivation. Economies of scale do free up resources that can be spent on front line education.

Given that the process of academisation – principally in the secondary sector – has gone so far that it would now be very hard to undo, the governing bodies of all academy trusts should be reminded of the words of Abraham Lincoln: 'Those who deny freedom to others deserve it not for themselves'.

Liz Coatman
State schools specialist for the Good Schools Guide Education Consultants

June 2016

The Good Schools Guide Blog


Related articles

  • Special Needs introduction

    Signs of special needs in school age children; how to get help; which type of school to choose; Education, Health and Care Plans ... Read more ... Need help? Perhaps you suspect your child has some learning difficulty and you would like advice on what you should do. Or perhaps it is becoming clear that your child's current school is not working for him or her, and you need help to find a mainstream school which has better SEN provision, or to find a special school which will best cater for your child's area of need.  Our SEN team helps…

  • The Good Schools Guide online subscription

    Find the best school for your child. One month subscription - £0.49 per day Three month subscription - £0.41 per day Six month subscription - £0.33 per day One year subscription - £0.29 per day Register for instant access to: ☑ Search for more than 30000 schools in our parent friendly interactive directory. ☑ Create and save lists of schools via My Schools. ☑ Use our comparison grid to get an exam results overview of schools you are interested in. ☑ Find comprehensive advice on state and independent schools, tutors and special needs. ☑ Receive our monthly newsletter. For further…

  • Where to find a state grammar school

    Identifying and locating grammar schools. Grammar schools are located in 36 English local authorities. Almost half of these are considered 'selective authorities' (eg Kent and Buckinghamshire), where around one in five local children are selected for grammar school entry based on ability. The others are areas such as Barnet or Kingston, with only a few grammar schools.

  • Choosing a school for a child with performing arts talents

    As proud parents, we all know our children are unique. They're smarter than anyone else's, funnier, certainly more attractive, better behaved and above all bursting with the kind of talent that would leave Daniel Radcliffe, Jamie Bell and Charlotte Church standing. And for some extraordinary - though totally understandable - reason, everyone but us seems blind to our offspring's God-given artistic gifts.

  • Boarding schools explained - the right choice?

    The headmaster/mistress runs the school but boarding houses are usually the domain of either houseparents or, in smaller schools, the head of boarding. Whilst the housemaster/mistress oversee the house, the day-to-day running is usually under the supervision of a matron.

Subscribe for instant access to in-depth reviews, data and catchment:

Comprehensive catchment maps for English state schools inc. year of entry.
 School exam results by subject and performance GCSE, Alevel or equivalent.
 Which schools pupils come from and go onto.
 Honest, opinionated and fearless independent reviews of more than 1,100+ schools.
 Overall school performance by GCSE, Alevel or equivalent.
 School data comparison by A/B weighted, relative success and popularity.
 Compare schools by qualities and results.
 Independent tutor company reviews.

Try before you buy - The Charter School Southwark

The Good Schools Guide subscription

 GSG Blog >    In the news >


Educational insight in your inbox. Sign up for our popular newsletters.

Transgender policy now needed in every school

3rd editions of Good Schools Guide - London North and South now available, all entries fully revised with 2016 results. Buy now...