Skip to main content

Dr John L Taylor, Director of Critical Skills, at Rugby School, and Chief Examiner for Edexcel Project Qualifications explain, why even Harvard professors are excited by the post-16 course that demands original research and thought.

With a myriad of courses on offer, plus year on year improvements in pass rates, it is seemingly harder than ever for savvy, innovative, intellectual students to shine and to take the right path.

Arguably, schools have become little more than exam factories, churning out an increasingly homogeneous product.

Learning is reduced to bite-sized chunks of information fed, absorbed and regurgitated at regular intervals; or is it?

Not always; Perspectives on Science is a course that has received critical acclaim from top flight universities for asking such questions as 'Are mental illnesses genetic?' and demanding a rigorously researched response.

Extended Project Qualifications - pushing the boundaries

Perspectives on Science is part of the EPQ .... 'My universities were amazed at the amount of independent work that was needed for this and they felt it would stand students in good stead.' Ellie Derrick.

Rare Breed

Developed by The Edexcel Examination Board in conjunction with teachers and academics, students undertaking an extended project qualification can earn up to 70 UCAS points, (just over half an A level).

'We believe Extended Projects have the potential to produce pupils who are better equipped for life at university and that they are a powerful educational tool which could transform the curriculum within schools by placing the emphasis on a pupil centred, active learning approach in an academically rigorous context.' Patrick Derham, Head Master, Westminster School.

There are various routes to extended project qualifications but courses such as Perspectives in Science and Digital Perspectives - which combine science, ethics and philosophy and feature case study discussions designed to develop skills in research, philosophical thinking and ethical argument - are held in very high regard. Students not only learn to question, analyse and philosophise, but push their skills to the limits when embarking on their individual and original research project dissertations.

It's not just at home where the course garners support; Professor Niall Ferguson, Harvard University comments,

'Five years of teaching in American universities has convinced me that English secondary education has two fundamental weaknesses. There is still too much reliance on exam-based assessment, which encourages cramming and learning by rote. And the A level system perpetuates the fatal 'two cultures' divide between arts and sciences. That's one reason that even stars from the best British schools find the going tough at Harvard. They're not ready for continuous assessment. And they're not ready to spend the morning on literature and the afternoon on physics. The appeal to me of the Extended Project, as exemplified by the Perspectives on Science course pioneered at Rugby, is that it offers a cure for both these problems.'

And according to Peter Stagg, University of Warwick Centre for Education and Industry, Perspectives on Science is particularly useful for employers, because it includes a range of work-related scenarios and uses. He believes,

'Teaching and learning styles which are very participative and open, encourage the development of some generic skills and enterprise capabilities valuable in employment. Other science A level courses could gain some insights into work-related learning and enterprise by incorporating some ideas from these courses.'

Original research

There is much here for both science and arts students who want to explore the interface between these domains.

The project phase allows students the chance to develop original thought; a structured approach is used to encourage academically rigorous research and writing. The Perspectives programme works best for those who can see the point of science and philosophy working together; who subscribe to, or are prepared to challenge the view

'There is more to the truth than just the facts’,

or who believe, as William James did that,

‘We have to live today by what truth we can get today, and be ready tomorrow to call it falsehood.'

Popular research questions include: 'Can you believe in God and the big bang?' and 'Is animal testing for cosmetic purposes ethically acceptable?' Less common questions such as 'What is the best philosophical interpretation of quantum mechanics?' often lead to work which a good undergraduate would be proud to have produced.

Causing a stir

Devotees of the course - both students and teachers - tend to be enormously enthusiastic.

'Probably the most enjoyable teaching I've done,' said one teacher.

Whilst a student regarded it as

'A more realistic, interesting and fascinating course than my other subjects.'

Unsurprisingly, Perspectives on Science is held in high esteem by leading universities and employers; so whatever path perspectives students take, they’re likely to go a long way.

Dr John Taylor was engaged in research and teaching at the University of Oxford before he joined Rugby School.

He has devoted much of his professional life to exploring philosophical questions with students and has the last word:

'The wonderful thing about philosophical discussion with students is the feeling of not knowing where the conversation will end up. In philosophy, an idea stands or falls by the clarity and logic of the argument behind it. It doesn't matter whose idea it is. It is wonderfully empowering to students once they realise that, when the great questions of philosophy are on the table, their ideas and arguments count too.'

For further information contact jlt@rugbyschool.net

Related articles


  • When to put your child’s name down for a school

    A handful of schools literally demand that you apply for a place as soon as your child is born, which means it’s never too early to start planning your child’s education. In fact, it’s a process that can start even before you’ve conceived – and that goes for all parents, wherever they want their offspring to go to school. From embryo to 18, read on to find out how to survive the education highway. Our lively look at education planning for children of all ages and their parents aims to guide you through the schooling stages in both the independent…

  • What school league tables do not tell you

    League tables have caused a lot of agony and misunderstanding. As raw statistics, they are more or less meaningless. You will observe, for a start, that results swing wildly according to which newspaper you happen to look at. Among other things they don’t tell you: the pupils’ IQs, school policy, examinations taken or quality of education overall.

  • Questions to ask when visiting a school - academic matters

    Don't rely on league tables  - look beyond the headlines. Check-out our detailed analysis of results for English state schools to uncover how well a school does for a child like yours. Whether the most able, least able or Annie Average, what matters is how enthusiastic the school is about teaching and developing a child.

  • Post 16 curricula and examinations

    What you study post-16 is likely to shape a huge chunk of your future. If you are considering university study or apprenticeships at 18, make sure you scrutinise course requirements before choosing your advanced level study courses. It's important to think about the type of examination you opt for - A level, Highers, Pre U, IB etc.

  • Curricula and exams for the middle years

    It's not only the type of qualification you need to think about; the subjects you opt to study at 14+ can have far reaching consequences on A level and beyond. Careers and university options may seem like distant dreams, but it's important you check out advanced course requirements now to ensure that your options will enable to you take the courses you want at A level and university.


Subscribe for instant access to in-depth reviews, data and catchment:

30,000 Independent, state and special schools in our parent-friendly interactive directory.
 School exam results by subject and performance GCSE, A level or equivalent.
 Which schools pupils come from and go onto.
 Honest, opinionated and fearless independent reviews of over 1,000 schools.
Comprehensive catchment maps for English state schools by year of entry.
School data comparison by results, relative success and popularity.
 Independent tutor company reviews.

Try before you buy - The Charter School Southwark

The Good Schools Guide subscription

GSG Blog >    In the news >

The Good Schools Guide newsletter

The Good Schools Guide Newsletter

Educational insight in your inbox. Sign up for our popular newsletters.

Is your child a future entrepreneur?

 
 

The fifth issue of Chalk & Chat, The Good Schools Guide’s exciting digital magazine, is out now.