Skip to main content


Grammar schools are they really what’s needed?

As the debate about grammar schools hots up and the Prime Minister herself seems to favour their reintroduction in a limited way, two experienced Good Schools Guide educationalists offer their contribution.

Bernadette John, The Good Schools Guide's Director of Special Needs, discusses key points about grammar schools

Grammar SchoolsIt’s hard to believe that a politician “accidentally” left details about grammar school proposals on view to a long lens. But it’s about time we had an honest debate about the privileged snapping up the best school places at all types of schools.

Yes, the sharp-elbowed middle class is disproportionately represented at grammar schools but so are they at faith schools, the best comprehensives, and free schools.

In the grammar school county of Kent, fewer children receive free school meals at its two most sought-after faith schools, than at the grammar schools. These schools demand church attendance on three out of every four Sundays – an easier ask when you do white collar jobs which don’t involve weekend working.

A study released by financial services provider, Santander, this week found that parents are prepared to pay premiums of up to £70,000 for a house in the catchment area of a desirable school, and that one in four has moved house in order to secure a school place. Lloyds Bank says that the average house near one of the best-performing 30 schools in England now costs £366,744, compared to a national average of £313,318. 

And, last month, data produced by analyst, School Dash, revealed that primary free schools stand out as some of the most biased against the poorer children in their locality, taking a lower proportion of disadvantaged pupils.

This isn’t right and, of course, we should be doing something about it – but why single out grammar schools?

They are an imperfect route but they do produce some degree of social mobility. It’s not generally mentioned but the 11+ isn’t quite the one-off test it is portrayed to be. There are effective appeals systems in place, whereby parents have an opportunity to present a case to show that their child is deserving of a grammar school place if they weren’t given one following the exam. At The Good Schools Guide, our service which helps parents to prepare for the appeal deals with those from a wide range of backgrounds and those we have helped include a homeless mother and several recent immigrants to the country.

Kent County Council already has a task force looking at ways to improve access to grammar schools for less privileged children.

I would suggest two measures.

  • We know that children develop at different rates, and in the independent sector, entrance points at 11 and 13 help to address this. Why not offer an expanded intake to the grammars at age 13, to allow for the late developers?
  • You are never going to stop motivated parents from doing all they can to give their child the best chance at the test. The way to equalise this is to remove money as the means to do so. Currently state primary schools are not allowed to tutor for the test while independent schools typically spend a year familiarising their pupils with the style of test questions and run extra tutoring sessions and mock exams in the summer holidays. Simply removing this ban would allow state schools to give their pupils a better chance.

Susan Hamlyn, Director of the Good Schools Guide Education Consultants, offers ten points to consider in the debate about grammar schools


  • comprehensive schools were truly comprehensive ie catering for everyone with whatever learning abilities, interests and capacities they have
  • we valued aptitude in technical, linguistic, practical, manual, creative and analytical skills equally
  • we had schools in which all types of learners could flourish without discrimination
  • we assessed and examined learners from the point of view of valuing what they can do rather than what they can't do
  • we saw education as a way to develop the whole person rather than as a process to produce members of an identikit workforce
  • we fostered a school culture in which aptitude and achievement in eg Latin or music was regarded as highly as in football or science
  • investment in teachers were regarded as the most important way to build our national future
  • further education and careers advice in our state schools were as good as that in most independents
  • we understood that we learn in different ways and at different speeds
  • we understood that separating children according to an arbitrary test of a few limited skills at 11 squanders vital talent and potential

we would not now be considering the reintroduction of grammar schools.



No comments received for Grammar schools are they really what’s needed?

Please login to post a comment.

Related articles

  • Finding a state grammar school

    There are currently around 164 state funded grammar schools located in 36 English local authorities, with around 167,000 pupils between them. There are a further 69 grammar schools in Northern Ireland, but none in Wales or Scotland. Almost half of these are considered 'selective authorities' (eg Kent and Buckinghamshire), where around one in five local children are selected for grammar school entry based on ability. The others are areas such as Barnet or Kingston, with only a few grammar schools. How to find a state grammar school Word of warning: not all selective grammar schools have 'grammar' in their name. Bournemouth…

  • Understanding the 11+

    This is the must read article for any parent of a child under eleven years of age who is contemplating a selective or independent school education. We unravel the mystery behind 11+ testing and examinations and explain what you need to do, when and how, to ensure maximum success for your child.

  • Grammar School Appeals

    Your child has passed the 11+, but has not been offered a grammar school place. Or perhaps your child has narrowly missed the required mark or has not performed as expected in the tests. What can you do?

  • Grammar schools - best value added

    We examined the value-added from KS2 to GCSE for 2015 to see which state selective grammar schools added the most value to their offspring. A note of caution - the more highly selective a grammar school, the less scope there will be to add value.

  • Grammar Schools - the politics

    Grammar schools continue to divide opinion. Supporters believe a grammar school education gives all children, regardless of social class, a passport to a good education and future. Detractors point out that grammar schools take very few pupils entitled to free school meals, and denounce them as elitist, divisive and damaging to the moral and esteem of children who feel themselves to be failures at the age of 11.

Subscribe for instant access to in-depth reviews, data and catchment:

30,000 Independent, state and special schools in our parent-friendly interactive directory.
 School exam results by subject and performance GCSE, A level or equivalent.
 Which schools pupils come from and go onto.
 Honest, opinionated and fearless independent reviews of over 1,000 schools.
Comprehensive catchment maps for English state schools by year of entry.
School data comparison by results, relative success and popularity.
 Independent tutor company reviews.

Try before you buy - The Charter School Southwark

The Good Schools Guide subscription

GSG Blog >    In the news >

The Good Schools Guide newsletter

The Good Schools Guide Newsletter

Educational insight in your inbox. Sign up for our popular newsletters.

Behind the scenes at The Good Schools Guide


For a limited time get one month's Good Schools Guide subscription free with any purchase of The Good Schools Guide to Boarding Schools.