Skip to main content


Empty exam hall | The Good Schools Guide18 August 2020

UCAS is unsung villain of A levels fiasco, says Ralph Lucas, editor-in-chief of The Good Schools Guide.

UCAS has known for years and years that something like 75% of pupils are over-predicted1, but have done nothing to improve things.

They know that disadvantaged children are particularly over-predicted – but have not, as far as I know, mounted a large-scale investigation into the reasons for this underperformance – which might have led to ways of reducing it.

The government could have, and should have, kicked UCAS into action.

They know in what schools for what subjects for what kind of child over-prediction (and indeed under-prediction) happens, and how much, and in what circumstances. 

UCAS allows universities to advertise inflated entry requirements, more than their student intake ever achieves. And worse they refuse to share this data with any other organisation which prevents scrutiny of such outlandish entry requirements - unless you're prepared to pay tens of thousands of pounds. All of which contributes to the practice of over prediction.

If we are going to use predicted grades in helping children and universities choose each other, they should be accurate. Regular detailed feedback from UCAS to schools, with real disincentives for long-term wayward prediction, should cure it in half a dozen years.

That would lay the groundwork for universities to build trust in schools’ evaluation of pupils – pupils that they have lived with up close for seven years, who they know better than the university ever will – and to choose their students based on a much richer appreciation than exam results alone can ever give.

We have allowed a system to develop where 20% of pupils seriously underachieve (relative to teacher predictions) inexplicably and contrary to their potential. UCAS has buried this, rather than throwing its energy into abolishing the waste of talent. This year, that lump of underachievement was (until the government changed its mind and accepted CAGs) visited at random on all candidates: the 20% who would have underperformed and the 80% who would not have.

We should take this opportunity to give UCAS a thorough going over. Its systems are old and inefficient, and yet again managed to crash on A Level results day - with a level of demand they somehow failed to predict It is owned by the universities, and acts in their interests – hence the great deficiency in the course information that is made available to pupils (even the most basic of information like the number of places available and the historic number of applications per course, what percentage of pupils drop out, why they drop out, and what jobs students end up in). Where else would you pay £50,000 based on such one-sided information?

With luck we will never be here again – but we should not let our anger go to waste. We should use it to power change.

One sensible (to my mind) solution would be to deny UCAS the monopoly of university applications - universities have to sign up to recruiting their applicants through them -  and let some pupil-centred organisations compete with them. Technology has moved on a long way since the centralised approach that UCAS first adopted back in the days when paper applications were the norm, and could easily handle a bit of diversity. 

Click here for The Good Schools Guide's latest advice regarding 2020's coronavirus-hit A levels and GCSE result.


Most popular Good Schools Guide articles

  • Special educational needs introduction

    Need help? Perhaps you suspect your child has some learning difficulty and you would like advice on what you should do. Or perhaps it is becoming clear that your child's current school is not working for him or her, and you need help to find a mainstream school which has better SEN provision, or to find a special school which will best cater for your child's area of need. Our SEN consultancy team advises on both special schools, and the mainstream schools with good SEN support, from reception through to the specialist colleges for 19+. Special Educational Needs Index

  • The Good Schools Guide International

    Find top international, British, IB and American schools in over 40 countries. The Good Schools Guide International publishes impartial and forthright reviews of international schools across the world.

  • Grammar schools best value added

    We examined the value-added from KS2 to GCSE for 2022 to see which state selective grammar schools added the most value to their offspring. A note of caution - the more highly selective a grammar school, the less scope there will be to add value.

  • Grammar schools in the UK

    Grammar schools are state-funded, academically selective senior schools. The education a child receives at grammar school is paid for by the state unlike at private schools which provide education for a fee. There are currently around 163 located in 36 English local authorities, with around 167,000 pupils between them. Northern Ireland has a further 67 grammar schools, but there are none in Wales or Scotland. A word of caution: there are private schools that have the word 'grammar' in their name but this is purely for historical reasons. 

  • Music, drama and dance at Performing Arts schools

    At specialist music, dance or performing arts schools, the arts aren't optional extras. They’re intrinsic to the school curriculum. Students are expected to fit in high level training and hours of practice alongside a full academic provision. It's a lot to ask any child to take on, but for those with exceptional performing ability this kind of education can be transformative.

Subscribe for instant access to in-depth reviews:

☑ 30,000 Independent, state and special schools in our parent-friendly interactive directory
☑ Instant access to in-depth UK school reviews
☑ Honest, opinionated and fearless independent reviews of over 1,200 schools
☑ Independent tutor company reviews

Try before you buy - The Charter School Southwark

Buy Now

GSG Blog >

The Good Schools Guide newsletter

Educational insight in your inbox. Sign up for our popular newsletters.


Our most recent newsletter: