Skip to main content


Shoes, socks and knees in a line at school | The Good Schools GuideLet’s get real about independent education

By Janette Wallis

There’s been a hullabaloo in the past few days about Labour proposing to abolish fee-paying schools, or more accurately to integrate them into the state sector. Most of this is party conference tub-thumping with a sprinkling of press embellishment. The excitement will die down and manifestos will mellow - it’s already happening. In the mean time, I thought I’d correct some of the magical thinking that surrounds independent education.

First off, independent isn’t always better. Some fee-paying schools are pretty dreadful, especially if they don’t suit your child. I am reminded of a comment from one of the founders of The Good Schools Guide, back in 1986, when asked her opinion of a famous boarding establishment: “I wouldn’t send a dead rabbit to that school”.

Independent isn’t always an academic advantage. There are plenty of non-selective independent schools, and even more that are virtually non-selective. This doesn’t make them bad schools, but parents are choosing them for something other than exam results - whether it be outstanding sport, warm friendship, or help with special educational needs.

Independent doesn’t always provide an old-boy network. One of the most outdated ideas about fee-paying schools is that attending them turns one into Boris Johnson, hobnobbing at Boodle’s, arranging work experience for godchildren and first jobs for nephews managing the mines in Rhodesia. A few schools do provide something a bit like this but, in truth, most don’t much. And nowadays, most professionals are too nervous about the faintest whiff of nepotism for connections to matter the way they once might have.

Independent doesn’t always lead to the top universities. On the contrary, universities are using contextual data to tease out the best pupils from poorer schools, which inevitably means fewer places going to applicants from independent schools. The best universities really do want to widen access to higher education. They really do want the most able pupils for their courses and go to quite a lot of trouble to identify them.

Independent isn’t always a cop-out from the state sector. Few families now can afford to fork out for their children’s entire education. Perhaps they pay for early years before moving to a village primary, or attend state schools up until sixth form when their children decide they need to board. We have clients who mess with all preconceptions by having one child at a grammar school, one at an independent and one at a comp. My neighbour’s son boards the daily school bus to the local comprehensive while his sister boards (with a bursary) at Marlborough College - one of the snazziest schools in the land.

Independent isn’t always British. Children come to the UK from around the world to spend money at our schools (supporting thousands of jobs, generating £550 million in annual tax rev-enues and expanding our so-called ‘soft power’ while they’re at it). Boarding schools are full of them. They get an education (and command of English), their British classmates have their horizons stretched, and our economy gets a healthy shot in the arm: win-win-win.

Independent isn’t always posh. Some very normal families really do scrimp and sacrifice to pay for their children’s education - we see them every day. 34 per cent of children at Independent School Council schools are from a minority ethnic background. The independent sector hasn’t won any friends by hiking fees faster than inflation, but ISC schools doled out £422m in means-tested assistance last year. And when affluent people do pay full fees at an ‘elite public school’, often with the help of grandparents or trust funds or investments from god-knows-where, isn’t it better to have that fortune out circulating in the economy - paying teachers, bus drivers and catering staff wages - rather than being handed on, untouched and swollen, to the next generation?

And finally, independent isn’t the only way parents get a leg-up in the academic arms race. How is sending your child to a fee-paying school different from moving to a rich area to be in catchment for an outstanding comp? Or hiring private tutors? Or going to church simply to gain admittance to a CofE school? Except that it's out in the open while the others are under the radar.




No comments received for Let’s Get Real About Independent Education

Please login to post a comment.

Most popular Good Schools Guide articles

  • Special educational needs introduction

    Need help? Perhaps you suspect your child has some learning difficulty and you would like advice on what you should do. Or perhaps it is becoming clear that your child's current school is not working for him or her, and you need help to find a mainstream school which has better SEN provision, or to find a special school which will best cater for your child's area of need. Our SEN consultancy team advises on both special schools, and the mainstream schools with good SEN support, from reception through to the specialist colleges for 19+. Special Educational Needs Index

  • Uni in the USA... and beyond

    The British guide to great universities from Harvard to Hong Kong. We tell you how to choose, how to apply, how to pay.

  • The Good Schools Guide International

    Corona Virus As a result of the coronavirus outbreak, The Good Schools Guide International offers the following guidance:  Determine the global situation and that of individual countries on government mandated school closures by accessing the UNESCO information on this link:   For updates on the medical situation, go to  the World Health Organisation website at  If you wish to contact one of our GSGI listed schools to discover their current status or any plans for alternate learning strategies, please go to our database to find email and phone numbers for each school If your company makes you brexit, The GSGI should be your first…

  • Schools for children with performing arts talents

    At specialist music, dance or performing arts schools, the arts aren't optional extras. They’re intrinsic to the school curriculum. Students are expected to fit in high level training and hours of practice alongside a full academic provision. It's a lot to ask any child to take on, but for those with exceptional performing ability this kind of education can be transformative.

  • Finding a state grammar school

      There are currently around 163 state funded grammar schools located in 36 English local authorities, with around 167,000 pupils between them. There are a further 69 grammar schools in Northern Ireland, but none in Wales or Scotland. Almost half of these are in what are considered 'selective authorities' (eg Kent and Buckinghamshire), where around one in five local children are selected for grammar school entry based on ability. The others are areas such as Barnet or Kingston, with only a few grammar schools. How to find a state grammar school Word of warning: not all selective grammar schools have…

Subscribe for instant access to in-depth reviews:

30,000 Independent, state and special schools in our parent-friendly interactive directory
 Instant access to in-depth UK school reviews
 Honest, opinionated and fearless independent reviews of over 1,000 schools
 Independent tutor company reviews

Try before you buy - The Charter School Southwark

The Good Schools Guide subscription

GSG Blog >

The Good Schools Guide newsletter

The Good Schools Guide Newsletter

Educational insight in your inbox. Sign up for our popular newsletters.

The Good Schools Guide manifesto for parents