Skip to main content


Moving the desks won’t make the results better

Bernadette John, our Director of Special Educational Needs, despairs at yet another pointless idea from The Department of Education

School admission policyThe school admissions system is, apparently, now taking the blame for the lack of social mobility which is blighting opportunities and depriving the nation of much-needed talent. The Department for Education (DoE) is reportedly asking academics and think tanks to come up with a new method which will prevent schools from filtering out less promising pupils.

The DoE is surprised that allowing a free-for-all in opening schools, and in enabling schools to become academies and to set their own admissions policy, has resulted in schools gaming it and avoiding admitting disadvantaged pupils.

What did they expect?

Parents already contend with immense challenges in gaining places for their children in schools they want – whether that is buying a house in the right street, spending their Sunday mornings at church or tutoring their child to get through selection. Can politicians not understand that, whatever system they come up with, parents will, as they always have, do whatever is necessary to get a place in a decent school - and the more affluent and socially advantaged will always find this easier?

Let’s wake up to the real problem: a lack of good schools. And let’s not waste money shifting statistics but spend it instead on resolving that, seemingly perpetual, problem.

There are swathes of the country where you have to be extremely sharp-elbowed to get a decent place. In the North and the Midlands, 28% of school places are in schools judged by Ofsted to be requiring improvement or inadequate. That means that more than 400,000 school places in these regions are ones no parent would choose.

In high population areas like London, there are simply not enough school places. Parents in Hammersmith, for example, have to name six choices of secondary school, yet around 12% of children will get none of these six and may well have to travel miles out of borough to go to school. In addition, faith school requirements mean that thousands of local children are disqualified from places at schools nearest to them.

Local authorities have been stripped of the power to set up new schools in areas of need. Instead free school operators can set them up wherever they choose with no particular regard to demand.

So let’s hand back powers to the local authorities – or create some other impartial authority to take responsibility - for the task of providing the number of school places equal to the number of school age children in their area. This ain't rocket science - or even particularly advanced maths.

School leaders have also proposed reforms to the school appeals system which, they complain, creates a huge workload and ties up staff. Malcolm Trobe, interim general secretary of the Association of School and College Leaders, told the TES that parents, “have got to have a genuine reason to be able to appeal, and not just appeal because they are not happy with the decision”.

It’s a confounding comment. We say parents have every right to challenge the decision if they feel their child will not thrive in the school allocated. None of the parents who have come to us for help with an appeal would have chosen to do so. Not one has appealed for other than serious and justifiable reasons.

If there were sufficient places in good quality schools, there would be far fewer appeals.

Why can everyone other than politicians see this?

January 2017



No comments received for Moving the desks won’t make the results better

Please login to post a comment.

Most popular Good Schools Guide articles

  • About the number one UK trusted school guide.

    The Good Schools Guide is the UK’s number one school guide, helping parents in every aspect of choosing the best education for their children. Trusted by parents for over 30 years, the guide includes unbiased and candid school reviews and in-depth articles on education-related issues. It is available in print, online to subscribers or through GSG’s expert consultants. Uniquely, each school is selected on merit alone. No one can buy their way into the GSG’s good books. And from famous names to local treasures, their writers visit every single school, interview the head, speak to pupils and parents, analyse academic…

  • For 'Grammar Schools' read 'Fee-Paying Schools'

    One criticism of grammar schools is that they take a disproportionate number of children from privileged backgrounds. A far smaller number of grammar school pupils receive the pupil premium than pupils in comprehensive schools.

  • Sad stories of wasted opportunities for children in need

    Buttle UK is a charity which supports disadvantaged children. One of its more imaginative and bolder initiatives has been to fund places at boarding schools for children who are thought likely to benefit from the opportunities this would provide. The project has been sensitively designed so as not to create divisions between children and their own families and social milieu.

  • Time and places

    The initial furore over National Offer Day is over - although, of course, the next one - Primary School Offer Day - is only six weeks away and we'll have to go through the whole miserable experience again. We, at The Good Schools Guide, along with everyone else, get worked up on behalf of children who are not allocated their first choice school or, far more worrying, children who get offered none of their six choices. It isn't good enough and shouldn't be happening.

  • Still under covers?

    Viewers tuning in for the Downton slot on Sunday night will have got something of a jolt – instead of cosy escapism, they were confronted by a brutal tale of death row executions and family betrayals (Undercover, BBC1).

Subscribe for instant access to in-depth reviews:

30,000 Independent, state and special schools in our parent-friendly interactive directory
 Instant access to in-depth UK school reviews
 Honest, opinionated and fearless independent reviews of over 1,000 schools
 Independent tutor company reviews

Try before you buy - The Charter School Southwark

The Good Schools Guide subscription

GSG Blog >

The Good Schools Guide newsletter

The Good Schools Guide Newsletter

Educational insight in your inbox. Sign up for our popular newsletters.

The Good Schools Guide manifesto for parents