Skip to main content

What says..

Parents report ‘a broad cross section of families’, mostly from central Edinburgh and suburbs.  Not really a toff school, although there will be a smattering. Taking over a third of Edinburgh’s independent secondary pupils, it is less elitist than some of its neighbours. The boys and girls are educated together at the junior school, separately in the senior school from 12-17 and back to a co-ed set up in their final year. As you would expect for the largest (joint) independent school in Europe, sport is massive...

Read review »

What the school says...

At Erskine Stewart's Melville family of independent schools, we offer boys and girls the best of both worlds. Our unique diamond structure plays to their individual academic strengths, while allowing them to enjoy social, sporting and recreational activities together.

At Stewart's Melville College your son can enjoy all the strengths of a traditional all boys' school. He will learn to master intellectual, physical and ethical challenges. As he develops his natural talents, he will grow in confidence, ambition and emotional intelligence. He will emerge an intelligent, responsible and compassionate citizen, fully equipped for the modern world. ...Read more

Do you know this school?

The schools we choose, and what we say about them, are founded on parents’ views. If you know this school, please share your views with us.

Please login to post a comment.

What The Good Schools Guide says


Since August 2018, Linda Moule, previously head of The Mary Erskine School. She runs the twin senior schools (Stewart’s Melville College and The Mary Erskine School) with two heads and the head of the co-ed junior school. She spends part of the week in each school (separate campuses) with offices in both. After graduating in theology from Manchester University, she has held positions in the teaching profession in Bristol, Stockport, Manchester and was deputy head of Holy Trinity College, Bromley, before becoming vice principal of New Hall School, Chelmsford in 2004. She was appointed head of Mary Erskine School in 2009, and became vice principal of the ESMS in 2016. Mrs Moule is married with two sons, both of whom have attended Stewart’s Melville College.

Head of Stewart’s Melville since 1999 is Neal Clark, a grammar school boy, studied English and came to ESMS via Kirkham Grammar School, Lancashire and then King Edward’s School, Bath.


At age 11, 12, 13, fifth year and sixth form. Automatic entrance from junior school. A broadly non-selective school. Children are assessed (English, maths, verbal reasoning) before entrance. Numbers are up. The waiting lists remain ‘first come, first served’ and there are no plans to cherry-pick the more able pupils.


Minimal leakage pre-Highers with most going on to university. Some 55 per cent to Scottish universities, the rest to English, Irish, European or American universities. In 2020, two to Oxbridge and three medics and one vet. SATS (for American colleges) not a problem.

Latest results

In 2019,, 59 per cent of Advanced Highers awarded A and 63 per cent of Highers awarded A.

Teaching and learning

ESMS follows the ‘diamond’ model of education. The boys and girls are educated together at the junior school, separately in the senior school from 12-17 and back to a co-ed set up in their final year. Principal and school heads are all strong advocates of this system: ‘we can tailor the teaching for boys and girls’…. ‘boys and girls learn differently’. The pupils ‘look forward to sixth form and don’t lose contact with each other as they go through’. Class sizes of around 20-22 for first two years - S1 and S2 - reducing in size to 20 or less for S3-S5 and then between 12-15 for the final year (sixth form). Parents of boys and girls see it as a ‘better learning environment’ and pupils say that ‘the separation doesn’t affect the friendships between the boys and girls’. Many of the sixth formers say ‘we have the same group of friends, boys and girls, as we did in the junior school; we don’t lose touch’.

Pupils study for eight National 5 exams in S3 and S4. English, mathematics, a science and a modern language are compulsory at this stage. In their penultimate year (S5), they study for five Higher exams while in their final year, they study for Advanced Highers in twinned classes with Mary Erskine.

Many pupils do three Advanced Highers (some do more) with considerable success. For these exams pupils have to undertake a dissertation and, in some cases, a scientific investigation which teaches them the skills of independent study that will be necessary at university. Recent results are strong for both exams. French, German, Latin and Spanish all on offer to Advanced Higher. The principal tells us ‘there is a strong work ethic here’. This was echoed by parents - ‘it’s a school that produces conscientious children’.

Strong links with the Merchant Company, whose members offer all final year pupils mock interview practice.

Firefly Learning, an online virtual learning platform, has recently been implemented throughout the school. This allows teachers and students to publish and access information from anywhere with an internet connection. Parents, staff and girls appreciate the effective system to keep track of homework, study tasks, school events and individuals’ progress in learning. Pupils do not bring in their own laptops but can sign out and use a school laptop (kept in school library) whenever they need to. However, pupils are still encouraged and expected to use books for their academic research as well as online resources (‘both are important skills’).

Pupils tell us that if there is anything academic that they need help with there are drop-in centres every lunchtime where a teacher is available to help them - in all subjects. Big, bright custom-built common room for sixth formers and study areas available.

Learning support and SEN

Strong learning support both in and out of the classroom. We hear reports of ‘great classroom assistants’.

The arts and extracurricular

Outstanding drama - ‘sport and the performing arts are equally strong here’. We hear from parents that drama is ‘quite extraordinary’. It is part of the curriculum for younger pupils and can be taken up to Higher and Advanced Higher. The Tom Fleming Centre for Performing Arts, at the Stewart’s Melville site, can seat audiences of up to 580. It's a renovated Victorian assembly hall - an impressive venue with comprehensive production, sound and lighting facilities. New acquisition Dean Church is another performance venue. Drama is for all, with plays and performances throughout the year for all age groups with regular performances at the Edinburgh Festival. Masses of orchestras and choirs at all age groups (22 bands, orchestras, ensembles and choirs running). Annual house music and house rock competitions, both keenly fought with performances described by one parent as ‘bloody amazing’. Choir performs annually at the Royal Edinburgh Military Tattoo. More than 200 boys have instrumental music lessons and there are 45 visiting music teachers. Pipe band thriving.

A staggering variety of clubs and societies on offer to all. It’s all here - from video editing to curling and everything in between. These take place at lunch time and post school. Many of the clubs are sporting - squash, football, netball - but there’s certainly something for everyone in the lineup. Good home economics. Voluntary CCF, very popular with over 300 pupils involved. Strong RAF - over 100. Even split between boys and girls. ESMS are the biggest provider over DofE in Scotland with large numbers getting gold awards.

Splendid art - and up to date displays around the school, wondrous paintings from this year’s art exams already up and framed on the walls. Schools often display fabulous art that we then discover has been hanging there for years. Here the boys and girls can see their creations being valued while they are still at school - when it matters most.


As you would expect for the largest (joint) independent school in Europe, sport is massive. Hockey, football and rugby are all strong (winners of U18 and U15 Scottish Schools’ Hockey Cup, of Scottish Schools’ Rugby Cup, of the Scottish Independent Schools’ FA Cup), but there are successes across the more minor sports as well with national accolades in swimming, kayaking, orienteering, golf, judo and climbing to name but a few. The main sports of rugby or hockey and cricket or athletics are compulsory for the younger pupils, but the choice widens further up the school. So, for those not so enamoured with team sports, there are plentiful options, including cycling, swimming and cross-country. The school puts out a very high number of teams so many pupils - around three-quarters - will get a chance to play matches against other schools.

The pitches at Stewart’s Melville are used mainly for the curriculum PE lessons and for afternoon sport boys are bussed to further school pitches at Inverleith. Swimming is popular and the school has a 25m swimming pool on site.


Only a tiny percentage of pupils board; this is still predominantly a day school. Dean Park House can accommodate up to 30 boarders. Handily located on site; boys only have a few minutes’ walk into their classes each morning. The house isn’t purpose built and it feels more like a large family house, well furnished and very well equipped. The bedroom sizes vary and accommodate between two and five boys. Sixth formers may have their own room, depending on numbers.

At weekends the boarders have planned activities offered to them such as surfing, cinema trips etc but they may also go into the city centre if they wish. The Sunday morning service in the local church remains compulsory to all boarders. They are free to use the school sports centres (pool and fitness suite) in the evening and over weekends.

Flexi-boarding is also on offer - but only if there’s space available.

Boarders come from Scotland, south of the border and also abroad. Often with family connections to the school (offspring of FPs - former pupils), expats. Predominantly UK citizens rather than foreign nationals.

Ethos and heritage

Stewart’s Melville campus (now with new £7m facility for classrooms, atrium, learning support etc) is based around the magnificent Daniel Stewart’s Hospital. Designed by David Rhind, it was opened in 1855 by the Merchant Company of Edinburgh. When Daniel Stewart (whose wealth came from India) died in 1814, he left a sum of money and instructions that, once it had reached £40,000, it should be used to create a hospital for needy boys within the city. The hospital was transformed into Daniel Stewart’s College in 1870. In 1972 the school merged with Melville College. The David Rhind main building is large and Victorian gothic in design. Think fairytale pile, now surrounded by some necessary modern additions. Games pitches to the front, mostly used for PE and by the junior school and car parks front and rear, chock full at the time of our visit.

Senior pupils share the site with upper junior school of ESMS. Sixth formers, who are back in the co-ed set-up with Mary Erskine, are bussed to classes between the two campuses, about a mile apart. Mind boggling timetabling but, according to both pupils and staff, it runs like clockwork.

Coaches from Dunfermline, Bathgate, Eskbank and Haddington as well as around Edinburgh.

Alumni include Tom Fleming, actor and broadcaster.

Pastoral care, inclusivity and discipline

The school runs a tutorial system for the first year with groups of 20 boys led by their form tutor, after which the school is divided into six houses. Each has a head of house and an assistant head who together look after the girls as they move through school. These houses are common to both Stewart’s Melville and Mary Erskine, so the various inter-house competitions have mixed teams. Weekly inter-house challenges range from maths quizzes to basketball matches. Sixth formers are under the divided into small tutor groups with a personal tutor, under the umbrella of the director of sixth form.

Excellent anti-bullying policy. ‘Cyberbullying in school aged children is now more of a threat than normal bullying’ and that they have a full programme to educate the pupils and make them aware of the pitfalls. We hear from parents that ‘any bullying shenanigans or friendship issues are handled very well and quickly’ and there is ‘fantastic pastoral care’. Sophisticated PSE programme throughout the school.

‘Zero tolerance’ and expulsion if pupils found in possession of, or dealing in, drugs of any kind. Booze and smoking normally end in suspension – ‘unacceptable but not an issue in school’.

Pupils and parents

A real mixture of parents. Many first time buyers and children of FPs (former pupils). Parents report ‘a broad cross section of families’, mostly from central Edinburgh and suburbs. Not really a toff school, although there will be a smattering. Taking over a third of Edinburgh’s independent secondary pupils, it is less elitist than some of its neighbours. Children living far out can spend the night when doing evening activities (as long as there’s room).

Money matters

Bursaries - up to 100 per cent - and scholarships throughout. Those doing well in the entrance exam are invited to sit a scholarship exam. Music scholarships (together with free music tuition) are also available.

The last word

This is a big school with big ambitions. With terrific success stories on every front, not just academically, it is a formidable operation. Not every child will thrive as a small fish in such a big pond and such a large operation may leave the non-conformist with less room to manoeuvre. However, its sheer size has tremendous benefits - parents report ‘the school pulls in great staff’ and provides pupils with ‘incredible opportunities’. Well mannered, ambitious children leave the school self-confident and ‘with a strong work ethic’. Parents across the board say they ‘can’t fault it’. An outstanding school with impressive results.

Special Education Needs

We offer support for learning, both in class and in small extracted groups. In the first year some pupils are given the option to do one modern language instead of two, allowing support to be delivered instead. Further up the school, some pupils will continue to follow a reduced timetable depending on their needs.

Condition Provision for in school
ASD - Autistic Spectrum Disorder Y
Aspergers Y
Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorders Y
CReSTeD registered for Dyslexia
Dyscalculia Y
Dysgraphia Y
Dyslexia Y
Dyspraxia Y
English as an additional language (EAL) Y
Has an entry in the Autism Services Directory
Has SEN unit or class
HI - Hearing Impairment Y
Hospital School
Mental health Y
MLD - Moderate Learning Difficulty
MSI - Multi-Sensory Impairment
Natspec Specialist Colleges
OTH - Other Difficulty/Disability Y
Other SpLD - Specific Learning Difficulty Y
PD - Physical Disability Y
PMLD - Profound and Multiple Learning Difficulty
SEMH - Social, Emotional and Mental Health
SLCN - Speech, Language and Communication
SLD - Severe Learning Difficulty
Special facilities for Visually Impaired
SpLD - Specific Learning Difficulty Y
VI - Visual Impairment Y

Who came from where

Subscribe for instant access to in-depth reviews:

30,000 Independent, state and special schools in our parent-friendly interactive directory
 Instant access to in-depth UK school reviews
 Honest, opinionated and fearless independent reviews of over 1,000 schools
 Independent tutor company reviews

Try before you buy - The Charter School Southwark

The Good Schools Guide subscription

GSG Blog >

The Good Schools Guide newsletter

The Good Schools Guide Newsletter

Educational insight in your inbox. Sign up for our popular newsletters.

The Good Schools Guide manifesto for parents