Skip to main content

There are three elements to fair comment: It must concern something of which you can have personal knowledge; It must be comment; It must be fair.

We may refuse to accept your comment if it does not fit with the Fair Comment guidance below.

You are allowed to defame a school if what you are saying is fair/honest comment, we will support your right to do so if you stay within the law.

There are three elements to fair comment:

  • It must concern something of which you can have personal knowledge
  • It must be comment
  • It must be fair

If you want to say something rude about a school you must make the basis of your opinion clear to the reader - that you are a current or former parent, for instance - and it must be a basis that entitles you to the opinion that you express.

It must also be clear to the reader that everything you say is comment, rather than a statement of fact.

In my opinion far too many good teachers have left since the new head arrived;

is fine,

Far too many good teachers have left since the new head arrived;

is not.

This may seem tedious, but it is the law. Telnikoff v Matusevitch [1992] UKHL 2, since you asked.

As to unfairness, only you and the school will know. The school would have to prove that no fair person could have held your opinion based on the facts as they were, or that your opinion was actuated by malice. We encourage schools to respond to comments, under the same rules as to what is fair and acceptable, but will in general not publish further comments in a thread unless we judge them useful, as opposed to entertaining, for our users.

You can expect a school to take a fair degree of commonplace criticism. You can call a school dilapidated, rowdy, ugly, evil smelling or anything similar without worrying that we might cut the comment for fear of offending the school (which it probably will).

But if you want to say something which will hit the school hard, such as stories of bullying, unresolved bad teaching, bad management, drugs/alcohol or any of the other common vices, you will need to consider what you want to say carefully. As your criticisms become more serious, there comes a point where, in order to sustain your criticism, you have to bring in facts, and to able to prove them.

"Parents of three children who left the school last term have told me that this was because they were being bullied, and in my opinion the school has done nothing to address the causes or adequately discipline the perpetrators" is a much more effective comment than "In my opinion the school has done nothing to address the causes of bullying or adequately discipline the perpetrators", but for us to publish it you would have to be able to show us that the facts stated were true - in this case by correspondence from the parents concerned. If the school then told us that your facts were wrong, you would have to furnish us with evidence that we could use in a court - in this case signed affidavits - to enable us to continue to publish your views.

You will make it much more difficult for us to publish a comment if you defame individuals, either by name or with sufficient information to enable identification. Schools (and school guides) are expected to be tough enough to take a good deal of criticism on the chin, but courts recognise that individuals can be much more vulnerable. The head teacher and the chair of governors are the only usual exceptions, but even with them we would want your fairness to shine through.

If we feel that you have strayed beyond the bounds of the lawful, we will decline to publish your comment. If we feel that you have strayed in one or two phrases only, we may, as an alternative, cut those phrases out. In either case, if we feel that we are missing out on a worthwhile comment for technical reasons, we may offer you an explanation for what we have done.

We are not permitted to alter the sense of what you have said to comply with the law - only you can do that if you wish to.



Related articles

  • Website access terms

    Standard terms and conditions for website access. Your access to and use of this site, provided by Lucas Publications is subject to these terms and conditions. Your use of this site constitutes your acceptance of these terms and conditions. Lucas Publications reserves the right to change these terms and conditions at any time by posting the changes on the site.

  • Child protection

    If you are preparing to entrust your child to a school – whether day or boarding – you will most likely assume that your child will be safe and that all members of the school's staff will take the greatest care to ensure that this is always the case.The chances are that your expectations will be fulfilled. Unfortunately, in a sad minority of cases that is not what happens.

  • Schools and the law: parent power prevails

    When to engage legal help. The vast majority of schools act fairly and provide good pastoral care; it is only occasionally that things go wrong. In those circumstances, it is my task to negotiate a fair settlement with the school, steering the parent away from proceedings, unless that is absolutely necessary. Parents need advice as to whether they have a genuine complaint or not.

  • Understanding the British school system

    Normal primary school admissions are at 3+ into the nursery or 4+ into the reception class. Some are divided into infant and junior schools, the latter starting at 7 years. Most secondary schools start at 11. For a normal application, you will need to apply – with a local address - by around mid-January for primary schools and the end of October of the year before entry for secondary schools.

  • Appealing for a school place

    Despite all you’ve heard about competition for places at the secondary school you want for your child, it’s still a huge shock when your offer comes through for Unpopular Academy instead. Don’t despair  - you have a legal right to appeal to any school named on your preference form. But it’s vital to have a back-up plan alongside going through the appeals process.

Subscribe for instant access to in-depth reviews, data and catchment:

30,000 Independent, state and special schools in our parent-friendly interactive directory.
 School exam results by subject and performance GCSE, A level or equivalent.
 Which schools pupils come from and go onto.
 Honest, opinionated and fearless independent reviews of over 1,000 schools.
Comprehensive catchment maps for English state schools by year of entry.
School data comparison by results, relative success and popularity.
 Independent tutor company reviews.

Try before you buy - The Charter School Southwark

**For a limited time get one month's Good Schools Guide subscription free with any purchase of The Good Schools Guide to Boarding Schools.**

The Good Schools Guide subscription

 GSG Blog >    In the news >

The Good Schools Guide newsletter

The Good Schools Guide Newsletter

Educational insight in your inbox. Sign up for our popular newsletters.

Career, relationship, children – can our daughters have it all?


For a limited time get one month's Good Schools Guide subscription free with any purchase of The Good Schools Guide to Boarding Schools.